I'm Your Teenage Prayer the beginning of his career through the present day-with the songwriter's edits to dozens of songs, appearing here for the first time. “A TEENAGE PRAYER” “A Tear Fell” could also easily be called “A Fool Am I in Love” (a line uttered frequently in the song). It's all about a young lady who. A Teenage Prayer. By Rachel Sweet. • 1 song, Play on Spotify. 1. A Teenage Prayer - Rachel Sweet. Featured on Cry-Baby.